When Jim Uhls was first given Chuck Palahniuk’s novel Fight Club to read it seemed unlikely that this was a book that would ever be realised on screen. Still, he thought, it would be interesting to be paid to adapt it into a screenplay. Roll forward and fates aligned that the project went into development and Jim Uhls was attached to write. Brad Pitt was cast in the Tyler Durden role, Edward Norton was an up and comer who was taking off with three great movies under his belt that year and Helena Bonham Carter had shed some of her Merchant Ivory image with a Woody Allen film she’d done, the sarcasm in that character suggesting she’d be great in the Marla role.
Jim’s approach to getting the story on screen effectively was to use narration but he wanted the voiceover to be it’s own thing and not inform the narrative. The irony of the voiceover is what lightens the movie and in fact during production when the early support group footage was shown to executives before the voiceover had been added they thought it was awful and dreary, proving that narration was required to fully convey the full narrative. There was a lot of narration though and so Jim decided to break it up at points and maintain interest by having the character talk directly to screen.
Writing this story for screen was a very different beast to the novel. When Jim changed things from the book they actually seemed more faithful to the book, which can happen with adaptation. The plane Jack meets Tyler on differed from the book but with his job flying around it seemed the most logical place in the film for a meeting and it works well shifting the power and authority of the story from Jack to Tyler. And though ‘His name was Robert Paulson’ line was from the book, the scene creating the circumstances of why it happened was invented by Jim. David Fincher added some things in too, like the action of Tyler riding a bike around in his house and he and Jim had great fun acting out things including the last scene to see how the dialogue worked.
Similar to story, Jim points out that you have to fully own characters as yours to write for them on screen but they still have to feel like they’re the author’s character from the book. It’s interesting to note that the character we know as Jack doesn’t have a name in the movie. Jim called him Jack on the page for his own convenience so he didn’t have to keep typing The Narrator, and the character reads writings in Tyler’s house during the movie that he quotes with ‘I am Jack’s..’ lines in the narrative but his name as Jack is never given or used.
The film follows a three act structure, something Jim Uhls knew he wanted, but he didn’t know at first where the demarcations would be, it was hard to figure out and the first act is long ending around the point that Jack phones Tyler. Before that call we see he has Marla’s number and that shot is included as a visual to bring Marla back into mind and maintain the connection between those two characters for the audience. This film is full of subtext. The halfway point is when Project Mayhem begins, the tone becoming more serious and worrisome from that position on. Toward the third act Jack becomes more peripheral to events and in the car crash scene the ‘friendship’ is unravelling.
Jim sometimes took things Jack had said in the book and split lines between him and Tyler to be more of a conversation that would show the characters bonding. Jim had to bear in mind all the time writing, the dual nature of the scenes, and how we’d view this in retrospect without the Tyler character. They had to work both ways. The early bonding Jim established between the characters pays off when the later questioning of Tyler’s motives by Jack seem more personal. The freedom to make choices with the story while still keeping the feel of the book was a good feeling, Jim tells us. Watching this iconic movie with the man who wrote those scenes and understanding how he crafted such a complicated adaptation into such poetry and sense was a good feeling too. Thanks Jim Uhls for taking time to come to London and share your incredible screenplay craft with us.
Leilani is an actor, screenwriter and filmmaker and has been blogging for the London Screenwriters’ Festival since it’s inception in 2010.








